STRS Ohio Lump Sum vs Monthly Survivor Benefit: How to Compare

The One Choice You Cannot Undo

When an active STRS Ohio member dies with five or more years of qualifying service credit, qualified survivors face a binary decision: take monthly survivor pension benefits for life or accept a one-time lump-sum refund of the member's accumulated contributions. This choice is irrevocable. Once the first monthly payment is processed or the refund check is issued, there's no going back.

The stakes extend beyond the immediate dollar amount. The decision also determines whether the family retains access to STRS Ohio health care coverage — a benefit that can be worth tens of thousands of dollars over a lifetime.

What the Lump Sum Includes

The refund consists of the deceased member's own accumulated contributions to STRS Ohio, plus statutory interest. If the member had three or more years of qualifying service credit, STRS Ohio adds a 50% statutory match to the refund — employer contributions equal to half of the member's account balance.

A member who contributed $85,000 over a 25-year career, with interest growth to $110,000, would yield a refund of approximately $165,000 (the $110,000 balance plus a $55,000 match). The exact amount depends on salary history, contribution rates, and the interest credited by the STRS board.

The after-tax portion of the refund — the member's own after-tax contributions — comes out tax-free. The rest is taxable, subject to mandatory 20% federal withholding unless rolled directly into a traditional IRA or eligible employer plan.

What the Monthly Benefit Provides

The monthly survivor benefit is a guaranteed lifetime payment calculated under whichever formula yields the highest amount: dependent-based (25% to 60% of Final Average Salary depending on the number of qualified survivors), service-based (29% to 60% of FAS for 20+ years of service), or retirement-based (calculated as if the member retired and chose Plan II Option 1).

For a member with a $65,000 Final Average Salary and 25 years of service, the service-based formula would pay 54% of FAS — roughly $2,925 per month, or $35,100 per year. Over 20 years, that totals $702,000 in lifetime payments, assuming no COLA adjustments. Against a lump-sum refund of $165,000, the monthly option's total value is substantially higher if the survivor lives two decades or more.

Health Care: The Hidden Factor

Survivors who elect monthly benefits may qualify for the STRS Ohio Health Care Program — medical, prescription drug, dental, and vision coverage — if the deceased member had at least 20 years of total service credit (for deaths on or after August 1, 2023). Survivors who take the lump-sum refund permanently forfeit STRS health care eligibility.

For a surviving spouse who is 58 years old and seven years away from Medicare eligibility, STRS health coverage can bridge the gap between the member's death and age 65. Without it, individual market health insurance in Ohio can run $600 to $1,200 per month, depending on age and plan level. Over seven years, that's $50,000 to $100,000 in premiums that STRS coverage partially subsidizes.

When the Lump Sum Makes More Sense

The lump sum may be the better choice when:

• The survivor has other income sources: A surviving spouse with their own pension, substantial savings, or continued employment may not need lifetime monthly payments.
• Health care access isn't at stake: If the member had fewer than 20 years of service credit, STRS health care isn't available regardless of which option is chosen.
• The survivor has significant debt: A lump sum can eliminate a mortgage or other obligations that monthly payments would take years to address.
• The survivor's life expectancy is uncertain: A surviving spouse with a serious health condition may receive more total value from the lump sum than from a monthly benefit that could end relatively soon.

When Monthly Benefits Make More Sense

Monthly benefits tend to favor survivors who:

• Need stable, predictable income: A guaranteed monthly payment removes market risk and budgeting uncertainty.
• Want STRS health care access: If the member met the service credit threshold, monthly benefits preserve this coverage.
• Expect a long retirement: A 55-year-old survivor with typical life expectancy will receive far more in cumulative monthly payments than the lump-sum alternative.
• Cannot manage a large sum: A $165,000 lump sum poorly invested or spent down too quickly provides no backstop. Monthly payments keep arriving regardless.

Getting the Numbers

STRS Ohio calculates the exact dollar amounts for both options based on the deceased member's actual account. Before making a decision, ask STRS to provide the monthly benefit amount under each formula and the total lump-sum refund available. Compare the breakeven point — how many months of survivor payments it takes to exceed the lump-sum total — and factor in health care costs, tax implications, and other income sources.

The STRS Ohio Survivor Benefits Guide includes a benefit comparison worksheet to organize these numbers side by side and identify which option aligns with the family's financial situation.

See more Ohio guides →