FRS Pension Plan vs Investment Plan: Which One at Retirement

The Core Difference

The FRS Pension Plan is a defined benefit — your monthly check is calculated from a formula (AFC × value multiplier × years of service) and paid for life regardless of market performance. The FRS Investment Plan is a defined contribution — your benefit equals whatever your account balance grows to from employer contributions, mandatory 3% employee contributions, and investment returns minus quarterly fees.

Both plans are administered by different agencies. The Division of Retirement at frs.fl.gov runs the Pension Plan. The State Board of Administration at myfrs.com runs the Investment Plan. That split matters when you retire, because the application process and payout mechanics are completely different.

Vesting and Eligibility

Pension Plan vesting depends on your tier. Tier I members (enrolled before July 1, 2011) vest after 6 years of creditable service. Tier II members vest after 8 years. If you leave FRS employment before vesting, you forfeit the employer-funded pension benefit entirely — though you can request a refund of your personal 3% contributions.

Investment Plan vesting is faster: one year of service. After that, you own both your employee contributions and all employer contributions in your account.

Payout Options Side by Side

Pension Plan: You choose one of four lifetime payout options when you file Form FRS-11o. Option 1 pays the maximum monthly benefit for your life only. Option 2 guarantees 120 months of payments to a beneficiary if you die within 10 years. Options 3 and 4 reduce your monthly check to provide a lifetime survivor annuity to a joint annuitant. The choice is permanent — once you cash or deposit your first check, you cannot change options.

Investment Plan: You take distributions however you want. Lump-sum cash payout (with mandatory 20% federal withholding), systematic monthly or quarterly withdrawals, direct rollover to an IRA or 401(k), or purchase a commercial annuity. There's no lock-in — you can change distribution methods at any point.

The Second Election

Every active FRS member gets one chance during their career to switch between the Pension Plan and the Investment Plan using Form ELE-2. This is a one-time, irrevocable decision.

Pension to Investment: The Division calculates the actuarial present value of your accrued Pension Plan benefit and transfers that dollar amount into a new Investment Plan account.

Investment to Pension: Your Investment Plan account balance transfers back to the Pension Plan to buy service credit. If your account balance is less than the calculated buyback cost, you pay the difference out of pocket. If it's more, the excess stays in the Investment Plan.

The Second Election deadline is your last day of active FRS employment. Once you terminate, the option expires permanently. Members approaching retirement sometimes use the Second Election to move from the Investment Plan back to the Pension Plan to lock in a guaranteed lifetime income stream — but the cost calculation can work against you if investment returns have been poor.

Retirement Mechanics

The Pension Plan requires a formal application (Form FR-11), employer certification, and notarized signatures. If the Division receives the application within 30 days after termination, the effective date is the first day of the following month; applications received later shift the effective date to the first day of the month following receipt.

The Investment Plan is simpler administratively. You request distributions online through MyFRS after meeting the waiting period. If you've reached normal retirement age, you can take a distribution of up to 10% of your account after one full calendar month of termination. If you haven't, you must wait three full calendar months before initiating any distribution.

DROP Access

Only Pension Plan members can enter the Deferred Retirement Option Program. During DROP, your monthly pension accumulates in the FRS Trust Fund at 4.0% annual interest for up to 96 months while you keep working and drawing your salary. Investment Plan members have no equivalent — when they stop working, they take their account balance and go.

For members weighing both plans near retirement, the Florida FRS Retirement Guide walks through the Second Election math and the payout-option trade-offs without recommending either plan.

See more Florida guides →