$0 Pension Credit Refusal Checklist

Pension Credit Tribunal: Evidence and Hearing Preparation

Why Preparation Decides the Outcome

The First-tier Tribunal re-examines your Pension Credit case from scratch. It is not bound by what DWP found — the panel forms its own view based on the evidence in front of it. That makes preparation the single most important factor. A well-organised bundle with clear documents often carries more weight than a barrister's advocacy.

Building Your Evidence Bundle

After you lodge the appeal, DWP prepares a response explaining how it reached the decision and sends you a copy, including the documents it relies on. DWP normally has 28 days to respond, but can ask the tribunal for more time.

Your job is to add your own evidence. Organise it as a numbered, indexed bundle:

Financial documents. Bank statements from the date of the decision showing actual balances (for capital disputes) or pension deposits (for income disputes). Three consecutive months of statements usually establish a clear pattern.

Pension provider evidence. Annual P60, pension payslips, or a letter from the scheme administrator confirming the gross and net amounts and the payment frequency. This is critical when DWP has counted a monthly pension as a weekly figure.

Capital disregard evidence. Funeral plan certificate, personal injury compensation award letter, or trust fund documentation if DWP counted an asset that should be disregarded under Schedule V of the State Pension Credit Regulations 2002.

Proof of delivery. Royal Mail Signed For receipts or certificates of posting if the refusal was based on DWP not receiving your documents.

Medical evidence (for late reconsideration or habitual residence cases). Hospital discharge summary, GP letter, or consultant report covering the relevant dates.

Number every page and create a contents page listing each document, its date, and its page number. The panel reads bundles from dozens of cases each week — a clear index makes it easier for them to find the evidence that supports your argument.

Review DWP's Bundle Carefully

When you receive DWP's bundle, read every page. Common issues to look for:

  • Missing documents you sent DWP during the claim. If your bank statements are not in the bundle, write to the tribunal noting the omission and attach your copies.
  • Internal notes that reveal a calculation error or an assumption the decision-maker made without evidence. These notes are often the strongest ammunition in an appeal.
  • Incorrect figures carried forward into the decision — pension amounts, capital totals, tariff income calculations that do not match the arithmetic.

Free Download

Get the Pension Credit Refusal Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

At the Hearing

The hearing is informal. The Tribunal Judge introduces the panel, outlines what the appeal is about, and asks you to explain your case.

Speak directly to the point. If the dispute is about an occupational pension counted at the wrong figure, say so: "My pension pays £150 a month into my bank account. DWP counted it as £150 a week. The payslips are at page 7 of my bundle." Do not retell the entire history of your claim — the panel has already read the papers.

The panel may ask you questions. Answer honestly. If you do not know something, say so. The hearing is a fact-finding exercise, not a trial — the panel is trying to work out the correct figures, not catch you out.

If you have a representative — a welfare rights adviser, Citizens Advice caseworker, or family member — they can present the case and answer questions on your behalf.

After the Decision

For an oral hearing, the tribunal usually gives you its decision on the day. For a paper hearing, the decision is sent by post and should arrive a day or two later.

If the appeal succeeds, DWP pays arrears back to the original decision date. If you lose, request a Written Statement of Reasons within one month — you need it if you want to consider an appeal to the Upper Tribunal on a point of law.

For tribunal worksheets, evidence checklists and a step-by-step hearing preparation guide, the Pension Credit Refused guide covers the full process from decision letter to tribunal day.

Get Your Free Pension Credit Refusal Checklist

Download the Pension Credit Refusal Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →