Pension Credit Overpayment Appeal: How to Challenge a Recovery Demand
Receiving a letter saying DWP overpaid your Pension Credit and wants hundreds or thousands of pounds back is alarming — especially on a fixed income. But an overpayment decision is not the final word. The amount, the recoverability, and sometimes the fact of overpayment itself can be challenged.
How Pension Credit Overpayments Happen
DWP identifies an overpayment when it decides you received more Pension Credit than you were entitled to during a past period. Common triggers include:
- A change of circumstances reported late — savings increased, a partner started receiving a pension, or someone moved in or out of the household
- A DWP review or data match — HMRC earnings data, bank information or pension records flagging income DWP did not know about
- An error in the original calculation — DWP's own mistake in assessing income or capital, discovered on review
The overpayment letter states the period, the amount DWP says you owe, and whether it considers the overpayment recoverable.
What You Can Challenge
An overpayment decision actually contains several separate questions, each of which can be disputed:
Was there an overpayment at all? If DWP's revised calculation is wrong — for example, it counted capital that should be disregarded, or used gross pension figures instead of net — the overpayment figure may be too high or non-existent.
Is the overpayment recoverable? Section 71 of the Social Security Administration Act 1992 allows recovery where an overpayment was caused by a failure to disclose or a misrepresentation of a material fact. Other statutory rules also allow recovery in some cases without either, including certain Pension Credit overpayments caused by late-paid income or another benefit, interim payments or specified direct-payment arrangements.
Is the amount correct? Even if an overpayment occurred, DWP must calculate the period and weekly amounts accurately. Check whether the period is right, whether underlying entitlement was correctly recalculated, and whether any offsetting underpayments apply.
The Challenge Process
Overpayment decisions carry the same statutory appeal rights as any Pension Credit decision. You have one calendar month from the decision letter to request a Mandatory Reconsideration.
In your request, be specific about which element you are challenging:
- If you dispute the calculation: provide corrected income, capital or circumstance evidence for the relevant period
- If you dispute recoverability: explain what you disclosed, when, and to whom — showing that DWP had the information but made the error
- If you dispute the amount: show the correct weekly figures and the correct overpayment period
If the Mandatory Reconsideration upholds the decision, you can appeal to the First-tier Tribunal. The tribunal can examine all three questions — whether an overpayment occurred, whether it is recoverable, and the correct amount.
Free Download
Get the Pension Credit Refusal Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Recovery While You Appeal
DWP policy is to suspend benefit deductions after it receives a Mandatory Reconsideration or appeal request, although there is no legal requirement to do so. Until the overpayment decision is overturned, DWP may continue recovery, typically by reducing ongoing Pension Credit payments. If deductions continue and cause hardship, you can ask DWP to reduce or suspend them. The standard maximum recovery varies by benefit and circumstances, but DWP has discretion to lower it.
If the appeal decision means more was recovered than is owed, the excess is refundable. If you have another outstanding debt, DWP may allocate the excess to that debt instead.
When It Is DWP's Error
If DWP accepts the overpayment was its error (sometimes called "official error") and it arose under a valid award, it is generally not recoverable under benefit legislation or common law, provided it was not caused by your failure to disclose or misrepresentation of a material fact.
Our Pension Credit Refused guide covers the full Mandatory Reconsideration and appeal process that applies to overpayment disputes, including deadlines, evidence preparation and what to expect at a tribunal hearing.
Get Your Free Pension Credit Refusal Checklist
Download the Pension Credit Refusal Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.