NYSLRS PFRS Survivor Benefits: Police and Fire Pension Death Benefits

How PFRS Death Benefits Differ from ERS

NYSLRS operates two separate systems: the Employees' Retirement System (ERS) for general state and local government employees, and the Police and Fire Retirement System (PFRS) for sworn police officers and firefighters. Both systems provide death benefits to survivors, but the benefit formulas, eligibility rules, and special provisions differ in important ways.

The most significant difference is in the ordinary death benefit calculation for active members. ERS members in Tiers 2–6 under standard plans receive a lump sum equal to one year's salary per year of service, capped at three years' salary; Tier 1 follows a separate formula. PFRS members in special plans — the 20-year and 25-year retirement programs under sections like 384-d and 384-e — receive a death benefit equal to three times the last year's salary, raised to the next highest multiple of $1,000, with no age-based reduction.

That "no age reduction" clause matters. ERS members in Tiers 2–6 under standard plans see their death benefit reduced by 4% for each year past age 62 (age 63 for Tier 6), down to a floor of 60% of the original benefit. PFRS special plan members and ERS correction officers are exempt from this reduction schedule. A PFRS member in a special plan is not subject to this age reduction.

PFRS Accidental Death Benefit

The accidental death benefit is where PFRS provisions are most protective. If a police officer or firefighter dies as the natural and proximate result of an accident sustained in the performance of duty — and not caused by willful negligence — the surviving spouse receives a lifetime pension equal to 50% of the member's Final Average Earnings (or last year's salary, whichever is more favorable under the applicable plan).

This benefit follows a strict statutory order that overrides any beneficiary designation on file: surviving spouse first, then dependent minor children (until age 18, or 23 if full-time students), then dependent parents. There is no option to redirect it to a non-dependent adult child or a domestic partner.

The accidental death benefit is offset dollar-for-dollar by any Workers' Compensation indemnity benefits paid on account of the same death. If the Workers' Compensation Board awards a surviving spouse $400 per week in death benefits, the NYSLRS accidental death pension is reduced by that amount.

Recent legislative changes have expanded protections for PFRS members. Heart presumption legislation enacted in 2023–2024 eliminated certain accident-notice filing requirements for accidental disability and accidental death benefits related to duty-related heart disease. Under the old rules, failure to file an accident report within 90 days (NYSLRS) or 30 days (employer) could bar the claim entirely. The heart presumption removes that barrier for qualifying cardiac events.

PFRS Tier Differences That Affect Survivors

PFRS currently has members in Tiers 2, 3, 5, and 6 (Tier 1 is functionally empty, and Tier 4 did not apply to PFRS members). The tier differences that most affect survivor claims:

Tier 3 (Article 14) — PFRS Tier 3 members may be subject to plan-level Social Security offsets that reduce the pension benefit when the survivor reaches age 62. This is a state plan provision, not the federal GPO or WEP (which were repealed in January 2025). Survivors of Tier 3 PFRS members should verify whether the Article 14 offset applies to their specific plan.

Tier 5 and 6 vesting — Both tiers now require 5 years of credited service for vesting, down from the original 10 years. This change, enacted in 2022, means that families of PFRS members who died with 5–9 years of service — previously ineligible for a vested death benefit — may now qualify.

Tier 6 FAE calculation — PFRS Tier 6 members retiring on or after April 1, 2024 use the highest 3 consecutive years of earnings for their Final Average Earnings, not 5 years. This can affect retirement and survivor benefits calculated using FAE; the ordinary death benefit for an active member is based on last year's earnings.

Tier 6 overtime cap — Effective January 1, 2027, the PFRS Tier 6 overtime cap increases from 15% to 25% of pensionable non-overtime earnings used in FAE calculations. Ask NYSLRS whether the change affects a particular death-benefit calculation.

ERS Correction Officers: The Exception

ERS correction officers are covered under ERS rather than PFRS, but their death benefit formula mirrors the PFRS special plans: three times the last year's salary, raised to the next highest multiple of $1,000, with no age-based reduction. They are, however, excluded from the post-retirement death benefit that other ERS retirees receive.

What Survivors of PFRS Members Should Do Differently

The claim process — reporting the death, submitting the certified death certificate, receiving the claim packet from NYSLRS — is functionally identical for ERS and PFRS survivors. The difference is in the benefit determination, particularly for line-of-duty deaths where the accidental death benefit is substantially more valuable than the ordinary death benefit.

If there is any possibility that the death was job-related, contact NYSLRS about filing an accidental death benefit application in addition to the ordinary death benefit claim. NYSLRS will investigate and determine eligibility. For deaths on or after January 1, 2020, the accidental death application must be filed within five years of the date of death.

The NYSLRS Survivor & Death Benefits Guide includes a side-by-side ERS vs. PFRS benefit comparison table and a line-of-duty death documentation checklist that covers the accident report, medical records, and Workers' Compensation coordination that PFRS families need.

See more New York guides →